Welcome to Bourbon, Brass & Beyond!
Nov. 15, 2026

Tasting Titans: Elijah Craig 21 vs. Heaven Hill 22 vs. Pappy Van Winkle 23

Tasting Titans: Elijah Craig 21 vs. Heaven Hill 22 vs. Pappy Van Winkle 23

Welcome back to the Bourbon, Brass & Beyond blog, where we take the deep-dive conversations from our microphones and expand them onto the digital page. If you are as obsessed with ultra-aged whiskey as we are, you know that finding yourself in the presence of one legendary bottle is cause for celebration. But what happens when you bring three of the most coveted, highly aged titans of the bourbon world together for a side-by-side comparison? That is exactly what we tackled in our latest studio session, and the results challenged everything we thought we knew about oak, proof, and prestige in the whiskey community.

Ultra-aged bourbon is a polarizing topic among enthusiasts. On one hand, you have the romance of decades spent interacting with charred American white oak, yielding complex secondary notes that younger whiskies simply cannot replicate. On the other hand, you face the specter of over-oaking, where the wood completely overwhelms the grain, leaving you with a tongue-numbing, tannic punch that tastes more like a furniture warehouse than a fine spirit. To find out where our trio of heavyweights landed on that spectrum, we uncorked the Elijah Craig 21-Year-Old, the Heaven Hill 22-Year-Old, and the legendary Pappy Van Winkle 23-Year-Old. If you want to hear the raw audio and listen to us debate these incredible pours in real time, make sure to check out our related podcast episode, Legends in the Glass: EC21 vs HH22 vs Pappy 23; Ep. 106.  We were very luck to have Chief Patrick Kilgore (ret.) from Chief's Bourbon Cabinet (IG and YouTube: @chiefsbourboncabinet) join us for this podcast.

Introduction: Tasting Titans in the Glass

Gathering a flight like this does not happen every day. These are bottles that sit at the absolute pinnacle of collecting and drinking culture. They represent massive investments of time, patience, and resources from legendary distilleries. When we sat down around the table, the air practically vibrated with anticipation. We weren't just tasting whiskey; we were tasting history, barrel management strategies from decades past, and the unique imprint of time.

Each of these three pours brings a completely different pedigree to the table. We have a low-proof traditional bourbon champion, a high-proof bruiser from the same distilling family, and the undisputed king of wheated bourbons. As we poured them out, we knew we were in for a rollercoaster of sensory experiences. Let us break down how this epic lineup came together and what we discovered as we explored these three magnificent monsters.

The Lineup: Elijah Craig 21, Heaven Hill 22, and Pappy Van Winkle 23

To truly appreciate a flight of this magnitude, you have to understand the contestants. First up in our lineup was the Elijah Craig 21-Year-Old, bottled at a very approachable 94 proof. One of our hosts actually recalls being first in line at the distillery when this particular expression was released, giving it a special place in his collection before the cork was even popped. It represents an era of patient aging where master distillers were letting traditional mash bills sleep for over two decades.

Next, we stepped up the intensity with the Heaven Hill 22-Year-Old. Clocking in at around 129 proof, this bottle immediately signals that it plays by a different set of rules. While the other two bottles in the flight sit comfortably below the century mark in terms of proof, this high-proof offering brings all the muscle of Heaven Hill’s traditional rickhouses straight to your glass, amplified by twenty-two years of evaporation and concentration.

Finally, we have the unicorn of the group: Pappy Van Winkle 23-Year-Old. This bottle carries a mythos that transcends the whiskey world entirely. Notably, the bottle we tasted was a 2019 release, meaning the juice inside dates all the way back to 1996 distilled at the historic Bernheim distillery. As the only wheated bourbon in our lineup, it relies on wheat instead of rye as its flavoring grain, promising a softer, sweeter profile to combat the immense influence of that 23-year oak maturation.

Nosing the Legends: Fruit, Oak, and Proof Differences

When you start nosing a flight of whiskey with this much age, the order of operations matters immensely. We began our journey with the Elijah Craig 21. Straight out of the bottle, even on a fresh crack, it completely stunned us. Instead of being dominated by dry, dusty wood, the nose exploded with vibrant fruit, rich oak, and a subtle touch of smoke. Remarkably, there was virtually no ethanol burn on the nose, allowing the delicate aromatics to shine through without any distraction.

Transitioning immediately from the 94-proof Elijah Craig to the robust Heaven Hill 22 was a jolt to the senses. The proof difference immediately announced itself on the rim of the glass. The nose on the Heaven Hill required a bit more respect and distance, as the massive alcohol vapors carried waves of deep, concentrated aromas. It was instantly clear that comparing this heavy hitter directly against lower-proof offerings was going to be an apples-to-oranges exercise, but an undeniably delicious one nonetheless.

Rounding out the nosing phase, we dove into the Pappy Van Winkle 23. True to its wheated heritage, the nose was noticeably more mellow, welcoming, and inviting. We encountered rich layers of creamy caramel, sweet baking spices, and a sophisticated, well-integrated oak presence. Critics of Pappy 23 often point the finger at excessive oak, but on this particular pour, we found a harmonious balance that kept us coming back to the glass for deeper sniffs.

On the Palate: Flavor Profiles and Side-by-Side Comparisons

Moving from the nose to the palate is where these ultra-aged bourbons truly reveal their character. We started back at the beginning of the flight with the Elijah Craig 21. On the tongue, it delivered on the promise of the nose with an absolute explosion of fruit notes. One of our hosts declared it his pick hands down, praising its elegance, complexity, and the complete absence of harsh astringency that sometimes plagues extra-aged spirits.

When we shifted over to the Heaven Hill 22, the flavor profile shifted dramatically. Despite the high proof, the palate revealed surprising layers of stone fruit and bright raspberry, woven together with deeper, earthier undertones. Because of its intense proof and heavy structural weight, the consensus around the table was that this is a whiskey that demands attention—and perhaps a fine cigar. It is bold, unapologetic, and packed with flavor.

Then came the Pappy 23. Sipping this legendary wheated bourbon was an exercise in luxurious texture. It coated the palate with a creamy, velvety mouthfeel, offering sweet caramel notes that transitioned gracefully into a long, satisfying finish. Every sip seemed to improve upon the last, proving that patience in the barrel can yield remarkable harmony when the distillate is right.

Behind the Bottle: Stories from the Visit with Preston Van Winkle

A tasting of this caliber naturally steers the conversation toward the people and families behind the labels. While enjoying the Pappy 23, we reflected on a recent, unforgettable two-and-a-half-hour visit with Preston Van Winkle. Sitting down with Preston gives you a profound appreciation for the legacy, family heritage, and immense responsibility that comes with bearing the Van Winkle name in the modern whiskey landscape.

During our time with him, the discussion ranged from the historical roots of the brand to incredible tasting memories, including experiencing a bottled-in-bond Old Fitzgerald from the 1960s. We also dove into the fascinating history of the juice inside our Pappy 23 bottle. Because it was a 2019 release containing 1996 distillate, Preston was actually able to identify the classic Bernheim profile simply by nosing it. Hearing those stories firsthand adds an irreplaceable layer of connection when you finally raise the glass to your lips.

Value, Pricing, and Market Realities

We cannot have a conversation about ultra-aged bourbon without addressing the elephant in the room: market realities, secondary pricing, and true value. In today’s hyper-inflated secondary market, bottles like Pappy 23 command astronomical sums that put them out of reach for the everyday enthusiast. However, looking at direct distillery pricing reveals a more grounded reality for some of these releases.

For instance, finding an Elijah Craig 21 directly at the distillery for around $299 completely shifts the value proposition. When you taste it side-by-side with bottles costing vastly more on the open market, the Elijah Craig stands tall, proving that you do not always have to mortgage your house to experience world-class, ultra-aged whiskey. We debated how these bottles stack up against Buffalo Trace and Heaven Hill lineups in general, noting that while the hype is real, savvy drinkers can still find extraordinary value if they know where and how to look.

Final Verdict: Which Ultra-Aged Pour Reigns Supreme?

So, after all the nosing, sipping, storytelling, and debating, which of these titans ultimately reigned supreme? The truth is, it depends entirely on what you are looking for in your glass on any given night. Our hosts ultimately landed on different favorites, proving that individual palates rule the day.

One host leaned heavily toward the luxurious, mellow sweetness of the Pappy 23. Another firmly cast his vote for the Elijah Craig 21, citing its fruit-forward complexity and ease of drinking. Meanwhile, the Heaven Hill 22 earned massive praise for its rich, punchy flavor profile and its unmatched potential as a pairing partner for a premium cigar. Our ultimate takeaway from this epic tasting is simple: every single one of these bottles is a number one contender. Because palates differ so wildly, nobody in the whiskey community is ever truly wrong about what they love.

If you enjoyed this breakdown and want to hear all the live reactions, laughs, and detailed tasting notes from our studio session, make sure to listen to the full podcast episode. Head over to Legends in the Glass: EC21 vs HH22 vs Pappy 23; Ep. 106 and join the conversation with us. Until next time, keep exploring your pour, pour it with people you love, and remember that the best whiskey in the world is the one you enjoy the most.

Related Episode

106
Nov. 15, 2026

Legends in the Glass: EC21 vs HH22 vs Pappy 23; Ep. 106

Bourbon, Brass & Beyond: Legends in the Glass- Elijah Craig 21 vs. Heaven Hill 22 vs. Pappy 23 Dan Sneddon, Bob Hird, and Chief Patrick Kilgore taste three well-aged bourbons side by side: Elijah Craig 21 (94 proof), Heaven Hill 22 (about 129 proof), and Pappy Van Winkle 23, the only wheated bourbon of the three. The bottle was signed by Preston Van Winkle, and the hosts share stories from a recent visit with him. The verdict: all three are "number one," depending on what you want that night. ...