Welcome to Bourbon, Brass & Beyond!
Nov. 15, 2026

Legends in the Glass: EC21 vs HH22 vs Pappy 23; Ep. 106

Legends in the Glass: EC21 vs HH22 vs Pappy 23;  Ep. 106
Bourbon, Brass & Beyond
Legends in the Glass: EC21 vs HH22 vs Pappy 23; Ep. 106

Key Takeaways

  • The hosts of Bourbon, Brass & Beyond taste-tested three well-aged bourbons side by side: Elijah Craig 21, Heaven Hill 22, and Pappy Van Winkle 23.
  • The Pappy 23 bottle featured in the episode was signed by Preston Van Winkle, and the hosts shared stories from their recent two-and-a-half-hour visit with him.
  • Preston Van Winkle was able to correctly identify the 2019 Pappy 23 juice as Bernheim distillate purely by smell.
  • While individual flavor preferences varied among the hosts, they concluded that all three premium pours are phenomenal depending on the desired flavor profile for the evening.
  • Elijah Craig 21 is available at the distillery for $299 and was noted by the hosts to stand up exceptionally well against the much higher-priced Pappy 23.

Bourbon, Brass & Beyond: Legends in the Glass- Elijah Craig 21 vs. Heaven Hill 22 vs. Pappy 23

Dan Sneddon, Bob Hird, and Chief Patrick Kilgore taste three well-aged bourbons side by side: Elijah Craig 21 (94 proof), Heaven Hill 22 (about 129 proof), and Pappy Van Winkle 23, the only wheated bourbon of the three. The bottle was signed by Preston Van Winkle, and the hosts share stories from a recent visit with him. The verdict: all three are "number one," depending on what you want that night.

#pappyvanwinkle #heavenhill #elijahcraig #pappy23 #heavenhill22 #elijahcraig21 #bourbon #oldripvanwinkledistillery #prestonvanwinkle #whiskey #bourbonbrassandbeyond #chiefsbourboncabinet #buffalotrace #oldfitzgerald #wheated #singlebarrel

Highlights
  • Elijah Craig 21: One host was first in line when the distillery released it. The nose brought lots of fruit, oak and some smoke. One host called it his pick "hands down," citing exploding fruit and no ethanol on a fresh bottle.
  • Heaven Hill 22: The proof came through on the nose after the Elijah Craig. On the palate the hosts found stone fruit, raspberry and softer flavors. They said it is hard to compare fairly against two lower-proof bottles, and one host would pair it with a cigar.
  • Pappy 23: More mellow, with creamy caramel, sweetness and oak. The hosts said it was long, approachable and kept getting better with each sip. They did not find the oakiness some people criticize.
  • The Pappy bottle: A 2019 bottle, which would mean 1996 distillate. Preston identified the juice as Bernheim by smell. One host still prefers Pappy 15 to 23.
  • Preston Van Winkle visit: About two and a half hours together. The hosts talked about his sense of legacy, family and responsibility, and a bottled-in-bond Old Fitzgerald from the 1960s.
  • Value: The hosts said Elijah Craig 21 is available at the distillery for $299 and stands up against Pappy 23.
  • Final picks: One host leaned Pappy, another chose Elijah Craig 21, and Heaven Hill 22 was praised for flavor and cigar pairing. Their closing point: palates differ, so nobody is wrong.
Timestamps
  • (0:01) Lineup and opening the bottles
  • (2:07) Pappy and cigars, plus the Heaven Hill 22
  • (3:22) Nosing all three
  • (4:37) Heaven Hill 22 nose and the proof gap
  • (5:28) Pappy 23 nose: wheated, mellow, oaky
  • (6:49) Nose favorites
  • (10:42) Moving to the palate
  • (11:23) Elijah Craig vs. Heaven Hill 22 flavors
  • (13:01) Pappy 23 palate
  • (14:34) Distillate story and Preston Van Winkle
  • (16:10) Legacy and family heritage
  • (18:08) Final picks
  • (22:29) Buffalo Trace, Heaven Hill and the market
  • (24:49) Elijah Craig 21 price and audience question
  • (25:52) Next episode: Old Fitzgerald
Quote

"Every one of them is a number one. It depends what you're looking for during that pour."

Cheif's Bourbon Cabinet - on IG, YouTube, and TikTok @chiefsbourboncabinet

Bourbon, Brass & Beyond - https://www.bourbonpod.com

or Link Tree - https://linktr.ee/BourbonBrassBeyond


Frequently Asked Questions

What bourbons were tasted in episode 106 of Bourbon, Brass & Beyond?

The hosts tasted Elijah Craig 21 (94 proof), Heaven Hill 22 (around 129 proof), and Pappy Van Winkle 23 side by side.

Who signed the Pappy 23 bottle featured on the show?

The Pappy 23 bottle was signed by Preston Van Winkle, whom the hosts recently spent time visiting.

What is the distillery price of Elijah Craig 21?

Elijah Craig 21 is available at the distillery for $299, offering great value and competing strongly against much more expensive bottles like Pappy 23.

Dan, Bob and Chief: Good evening. Welcome back to Bourbon Brass and Beyond. tonight it's a quick battle. I I feel like we talked about this, but now I regret doing quick battle on you know super well-aged. Yeah, how do you do a quick battle juice? How do you do quick battle? Look at this lineup, folks. Okay. You're talking about Elijah Craig, 21, right? Heaven Hill, 22, and then the old granddad himself. Come on right there. The Pappy 23. And we're gonna do this quick. Wow. Well, you do the honor, sir. I'm gonna open this up. All right, so if anybody's watched Chief's Bourbon Cabinet, y'all know I love the pop. And I don't think there's any greater sound in the world other than sound of a brand new baby coming into the world. Other than that, it's right here. And what a pleasure. Thank you for allowing me to do this. Let's see. How good of a pop is it? Ready? Whoa, that's okay, that's a strike right now, I'm telling you. That's a strike. I've not had this one before. I'm actually excited. So I was very fortunate when Elijah Craig, Heaven Hill, made this public at the distillery. I was number one in line. And I was very fortunate to be there. And tell me you're an Elijah Craig fan without telling me you're not Elijah Craig fan. got to meet the master distillers and the people in line. I I made one of my my best friends, there, Brian Florence. And I what do you say we we go all three against each other? Yeah. All right. Right? All right. So bottle number two. What we did on the last podcast. It is the Heaven Hill twenty two. I cheated and I got bad news for you guys. What's that? And then the last one. if we have to. Yeah. If you go off, you're gonna make me do it. So what's interesting is is Preston and Julian only drink to twenty three when they're doing cigars. talking about cigars. Yeah. Right. It was such a good experience with him too. that guy is, whoa, buddy. Hey you want to keep the bigger one? Give me a short pour. I feel like he doesn't realize that the two looks bigger on the bottom. I know. I guess I'll keep that I cannot wait. So they they do that primarily with cigars because they feel like that that's the the flavor and the taste of it needs a cigar to either tamper it down or to accentuate it. But I really liked it, cigar or not. But all right, let's do the nose first. Okay. Across all three we're going. Yep. I'm getting a lot of fruit. Yeah. A ton of fruit and oak. So we just came off twenty two. Kevin Hill, twenty two. So this is the twenty one, right? Yeah. So this is a Logic Craig? Twenty I'm getting a little smoke on there too. Me too. man. That's the part I was gonna that I I think the nose on this is really, really good. Yeah. That's phenomenal. Proofs? Are they all someone? Sorry. So Borrel 35. No, you really you're looking at what? Does it say where's it at? Ninety-four. Okay. yeah, you're right. 94 proof. Elisha Craig, 94. and I don't want to hear any haters about it's only ninety-four because what is this? Ninety five point six. Ninety five, right? What recognized throughout the world as probably one of the best sought after bourbons. So all right. So Okay. Yeah, that's fantastic. So coming back to this Heaven Hill, after that Elijah Craig, I feel like this has got a a much stronger ethanol on it. Yes. Now you really that's Correct. Yeah. Correct. The the proof comes through and maybe that's what it is. I say ethanol, maybe I should just say proof. Well, you're right. Okay. So yeah, so we're hitting Yeah. You know, in the nineties. Yeah, it's a j it's a leap. It's it's a leap. Yeah. I really d I think y you can only really compare taste when it comes to something like that, right? Yeah. For right now, man, I just that Elijah Craig, twenty one. All right, I'm gonna go to the twenty three. Mm. Now and this is the only one that's a wheater. Yep. I think it's go ahead. I was gonna say you get a lot of oak. A lot of I I was gonna say it's much more mellow than the other two. It is. It is. But that oak really comes through. It does. Yeah. I gotta go back to that. I would They're really, really close. They're really close. I It's like ice cream caramel. Yeah. Like that's what I get with that that Pappy twenty three. It's like a it's like a sweet Yeah. Creamy caramel. And for what it's worth the this Heaven Hill twenty two is it's it's gotta be the proof. 'Cause it it's got a nice nose, but I it's the proof. It's the proof. It's the proof. Because when we compared it to the other two. Yeah, it was the the ethanol then come right through. But when you're looking at two considerably lower proof, you know, it's just it's gonna go side by side, yeah, twenty one to twenty three and Yeah. I don't know. What do you think do you have a do you have a favorite up for the nose? I think for the nose. I I like the fruit, but I I'm a huge caramel fan, so caramel and oat. Mm. What do you say? Yeah. I do like the fruit on the Elijah Craig twenty one. I I I like that. If I was just gonna go play pure nose, I I think that I would like the nose on that the most. 23 is delicious though. I'm not getting as much fruit on it though when I go back to it on the nose. I think I get more when I come back to it. If I just go back and forth, I almost think that the I don't believe I'm gonna say these words. The Pappy23 does not have the same amount of nose on it as either of the others. I think this Elijah Craig 21 is really, really good on the nose. To your point, there's only one of these that's a wheater, maybe that's the difference. I remember we just cracked this open. That's fair. But the there is something that is very mellow with this that exists with the age. I don't know if you want to call that more refined or not. I don't May I I get more on the Elijah Craig than I do on the Pappy. I would say for me I'm surprised to be able to say this for me, hands down, is the Elijah Craig 21. It's pretty cool. I think the fruit is just exploding. especially for a fresh crack. I'm not mad that there's no there's not any ethanol coming through here. I'll agree. Right on that, for especially for a fresh crack. the fruit, I think it's got everything that I'm looking for on an aged Are you being a homer right now? Yeah, I'm just saying it's really good. It is really really good. You know, and I'm telling you, there's there's nothing d these are incredible bottles. I and I think that's to your point, is that Elijah Craig twenty one versus Pappy twenty three. Yes. When we talk about availability and price, we're on two different markets right now. No, I just went back to the nose on all three of them. Yeah. And I think they seem completely different to me. All three like different from each other? I agree. Well but I think that I'm getting a lot more flavor from the Pappy twenty-three and I'm getting less flavor from the twenty-one. That twenty two is so good though. Right. I mean they're they're all fantastic. The twenty three is very, very approachable. I and when I say it's it's almost it's so enjoyable. It it wants to pull you in. Yeah. Like it's a like you can bury your nose in this glass and not get overwhelmed by it. Yeah. But I'm getting more of the the sweet beyond the caramel now out of the Pappy twenty three. I agree. And I'm getting less of the fruit on the Elijah Craig twenty one and more of the oak, more of the the smoke. I definitely let it so good. Well what I said but when we cracked it open, the smoke, you got the fruit and the smoke. I'm getting more oak on the on the Pappy twenty three. We created ourselves such a good problem right here. Yeah, right? Okay, 'cause you know right. There's no there isn't any loser There's no first or second or third place, Yeah, that's gonna be the problem. Because all three are different. Yep. All three are different. Okay. Let's go to the palette. here we go. Citrusy? Is that what that is? Can I just do this? Yeah. Well done. Well done, Elijah Craig. Thank you. It's really Yeah. After the proof that we had on that Heaven Hill coming down like this, it's still so good in there. Yeah. I would say that flavor equals the Heaven Hill twenty two. Even though that's only ninety four proof. Yes. No, you're right. Yeah. And that one's one twenty nine? Yes. Without the proofiness. You're gonna get blown out, right? That Heaven Hill's delicious. It is delicious. I'm sorry, that is they're both I'm getting more of the stone fruit and more of the fruit flavors on the twenty two than I am the twenty one. Yes. I would say that to me the palette is better on the twenty two than the twenty-one. Well, this is a hard. Yeah. I think I'm getting more softer Raspberry. that's a great point that the there are softer flavors softer flavors in this on the lower proof because they're not proofed out I agree with that yeah yeah that I would if I'm looking at just these two right now that 22 is yeah that 22 is just really it's really there yeah and it's so hard because it it's how do you how do you look at Something in the nineties and something that's just a couple of points away from being a one hundred thirty. Yeah, I think that's the it's a very tough comparison. All right, so let but let's jump into twenty three. if I have to. Let's see what the king says. Pappy, I love you. By the way, this is a signed bottle. Preston Preston Van Winkle. Preston, thank you for hosting us. Preston, thank you for the time. You are amazing. I you don't sorry. I just this is a reason why it's the king. It is delicious. I ha listen, we spent two and a half hours with him while we were there. Amazing experience. I never in the world would I have thought that I got to sit and hang out like that. It was such a good experience. The nose is pretty darn good on this. And the flavor just just lasts. I mean it just This is long. The it's long. Disc is a complete palette. Just washes to the palate. I've heard a lot of if anything I've heard is if anybody has anything negative to say about the twenty three, they say it's so oaky. I'm not getting that. No. I'm not getting that. I'm sorry. Not after the things we've been through, I'll agree. No. no. these are I take back three distinct Yes. Very true. Three distinct whiskies. I've always said that I like the 15 better than thank you. Let me be very clear. Thank you. Wouldn't be without you. 15 is better than 23, but dear lord, is that 23 really now? my god. So funny story. This is a 2019 bottle. Okay. Which means it was distilled before Buffalo Trace. And Julian was sourcing select barrels from different places. So I asked Preston during our podcast, I said, Do you know in twenty nineteen you it would so it would have been nineteen ninety six, do you know what juice they were using? And he goes, if I smell it, I'll tell you. So when I pop the cork, I open it and I go, Okay, what juice is it? And goes, that's Bernheim. Gave it back to me. Like without without Yeah, it was Again, it was an amazing two and a half hours. I it it was all of the things you think about bourbon upside down and you realize shit, I don't know what the hell I'm talking this guy gets it. Yeah. it was like his first time having the old Fitzgerald, the what what we tried upstairs as our warm-up was when he was teething. You know, that's what they rubbed on it. On it you figure that's what they used for coughs was old Fitzgerald. Hundred Proof bottled in bond from the nineteen sixties. Holy cow. It's amazing. I would I would say though, when you look at all of our professions, right? 'Cause I would hate to try to get into a cockpit of a plane. I'd do it a second. Can we go to the simulators? Okay, right. And you're not just a pilot, you're also an instructor. Right. Right. So I wouldn't want to compete against that. And from what your challenges that you're telling me right now that you're going through, you know, I I wouldn't want to do it. And what you're from what I was d doing for counterintelligence, right? we would all Yeah, I wanna deal with that either. Yeah. We I wish we had a job that all we had to worry about was bourbon. Yeah. Right. Right and stuff like that. But you think about the family heritage that he's got going on and what the the weight on his shoulders to maintain that. Yeah. The integrity, the the flavor. I I that part became very aware from him. He was you heard him talk about legacy and family and try and responsibility, you or is what he talked about. And it was very, very real to me to hear him talk about it. But we are also with the other side where what's it like to be Bourbon royalty? And he's got like I that was the part that was just well, he was like, you gotta remember when I was started doing this, nobody would buy our stuff. Because I was yes. I was going around pouring in people's mouths. Buffalo Trace was at one time that's the part that was always amazing to me. So I it's cherry, it's vanilla, it's it's everything. I can make my decisions right now. I don't have to go back through these. I I'm gonna be different than all of you. I don't even what I want. I think I just going I just did it again. For me, it's Elijah Craig. It's really, really good. Elijah Craig 21. The fruit just it really depends on what you're looking for, right? Yeah. And that's that's the thing. That's the key. Everybody's palate is different. Yes. Yeah. And it's it's those flavors that you look for in the things that like y when you go to buy ice cream You don't go, what's the best flavor you guys have? No, you're looking for a flavor specific to you. To me, I'm I'm looking for that old Fitzgerald, that old the the Pappy flavors. I love that wheated the old wheated guy. I'm a wheated guy. But but then again, if you are a a passionate bourbon, I'm gonna grab a cigar, it's hard to beat that heavenhill twenty two. I can see that. You know what I mean? And it right? So who's wrong? Nobody. Nobody's wrong on this. And personal preferences, personal for a reason. You know, it we all I I think we're all kind of maybe different. But what was yours? It's gonna be the Pappy. This right. I actually don't think this is fair to the Heaven Hill twenty two because of the proof difference. I it I think it gets blown out of the water immediately. I think it comes back to the Elijah Craig or the Pappy. The nose is really, really good on this. But every sip of that Pappy just keeps getting better. It's crazy. The drinkability drinkability is huge. It's crazy. Yeah. but so I really, really love the flavor on the Heaven Hell 22. Yeah. But I lean towards the Pappy. And and it's not just a mental thing, it's just those are the flavors I like. Can I take this home? Yeah. across the street? I am taking this away do that. I'm I'm telling you, every one of them are number one. They're all good. Yes. Yeah. They're number one. And then even depending on the night I'm looking for, I'm gonna I'm gonna grab the the Heaven Hill if I'm gonna sit down with a cigar and right? Yeah, yeah, yes. Right? I see this. every one of is a number one. That's what I'm telling you. Is if you can go by taste and don't look at anything else, you you're gonna open up and you're gonna find in a world that there's much more out there that you're really going to enjoy and you're gonna love. Yeah. Every one of these are number one. It depends what I'm looking for that night or that day. I agree. It's really drinkable. That Elijah Craig is really, really There it is. Can't go wrong, folks, right there. Battle Royale. Three fantastic. It might not have been what you were looking for tonight, because I'm telling you, every one of them is a number one. Yep. It depends what you're looking for during that pour. Fantastic. Outstanding. Thank you so much for making this happen. You bet. You bet. Thanks for being a part of it. This is this is what this is about. Yeah. I'm just gonna sit here and smile my Pappy for a while. Well. God, it's so good. I'll tell you right now. Yeah, well. It's so delicious. It's so good. Why was I How was I short on this? I don't know. It's so good. Maybe it's just comparatively. do we have to throw a Pappy fifteen in just to No. No, but you look at it, right? Elijah Craig 21. Just got released. Yeah. Pappy twenty three. King. It's the king. It's the world's king. It's a twenty nineteen. Like, I wonder how much some of this has to do with it too. We've had this before. I've had this before. Would this be as good as the Buffalo Trace juice? The other thing that he said, and I gotta give him credit, was that Buffalo Trace, they didn't they didn't turn down a single barrel from what they had for this year. Buffalo Trace was so consistent and so good, every single barrel met the expectation. Well Which says something to me. Yeah, you're right. There's a reason why I think right now Buffalo Trace is recognized as probably The best. Are they the only ones still producing too? The best. Whiskey bourbon producer in the world right now. When you say Buffalo Trace, everybody knows what you're talking about. Everybody can recognize a bottle that they absolutely love. You know, either it's a Weller, it's a it's a Pappy, it's a seventeen ninety two. I mean, there's so much going on with Buffalo Trace, right? It's the traveler. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I know I disagree with you on the traveler. But at the same time, there's a reason why the world's largest family owned. Distiller out there is Heaven Hill. Yeah. Right? They are knocking it out of the park. When you think about you want something lower fighting cock, $19. You want something, you know, top notch at the higher premium level. I mean, there's stuff higher than than the than the Heaven Hill twenty two right now. I mean, they've got some stuff, right? Mellow corn. Yeah, well I wore my shirt there. You got my shirt. Mallow. F and Corn. Right. F and corn. So what we're looking at tonight, we're looking at two powerhouses in the industry right now, right? And and there's a reason why they're at the top of their game, right? Yeah. So when when right now the market is people are saying, hey, it's declining and things like that, guess what? Guess who is benefiting right now? all of us. All of us right now are benefiting right now on this stuff. Because you can go right now, this Elijah Craig twenty one, you can go to the distillery right now, they're selling it for two ninety nine for a twenty one year. Yeah. And we all just said that it sits up against Pappy, by the way. Twenty three. We all just said that. Yeah, we just said, yeah, it's standing up against it. Yes, you did. So if you try this, tell me your opinion. drop it in the comments. let Dan and I know. What are you seeing out there? What have you experienced? What is your favorite? You know, what are you looking for when you're looking at a premium bourbon? You know? what are you what what flavors are you looking for? Yeah, we appreciate it. And how should we compare these on the next one? That's the That's the big one. Well, I'm telling you what I think the next step is. Is man, we haven't even looked at some of the old Fitzgerald yet. I gotta go to bed. Talk about some heavy hitters, you know. But that's another show down the line, folks. Thanks for watching. please like, subscribe, share, leave comments, please. We do appreciate it. Chief's Bourbon Cabinet. you're on YouTube, Instagram Instagram, TikTok, right? And all I have to say to everybody out there, good bourbon, good stories, meet you at the camp. Have a good night, everybody. Appreciate it. This is That is good. I'm not giving it up.

Related to this Episode

Tasting Titans: Elijah Craig 21 vs. Heaven Hill 22 vs. Pappy Van Winkle 23

Welcome back to the Bourbon, Brass & Beyond blog, where we take the deep-dive conversations from our microphones and expand them onto the digital page. If you are as obsessed with ultra-aged whiskey as we are, you know that finding yourself in the p…