The Sweet Spot: Why 107 Proof is the Ultimate Bourbon Sweet Spot
Welcome back, whiskey lovers! If you have spent any time diving deep into the modern bourbon landscape, you know that the community is currently obsessed with extremes. On one end of the spectrum, we have standard 80-to-90 proof bottles that often get criticized by enthusiasts for being watered down and stripped of character. On the other end, we have the monster cask strength and barrel proof releases that routinely clock in north of 120, 130, or even 140 proof. While there is certainly a time and a place for a tongue-numbing, hazmat-level pour, Nick Hardy (@nickfrom330) and I recently sat down to explore a very specific, highly optimized ABV that we believe represents the absolute pinnacle of whiskey enjoyment: 107 proof.
In this post, we are going to expand on our recent tasting session, breaking down the science and sensory experience of mid-proof pours, reviewing the specific heavy hitters and disappointments from our lineup, and explaining why 107 proof just might be the most versatile number in the entire world of bourbon.
The Science and Sensory Experience of Mid-Proof Pours
Why 107 proof? What is it about this specific numerical designation that makes enthusiasts swoon? To understand the magic of mid-proof bourbon, we have to look at the intersection of chemistry and human sensory perception. When a whiskey sits right around 53.5% alcohol by volume (ABV), it hits a rare thermodynamic and olfactory sweet spot.
When you pour a barrel-proof whiskey at 130 proof, the sheer volume of ethanol vapor rising out of the glass can easily overpower your olfactory receptors. That aggressive burn acts as a sensory shield, numbing your palate and making it genuinely difficult to pick out subtle notes of caramel, baking spice, oak, and dark fruit without heavily diluting the glass with water or letting it sit for an hour. Conversely, lower-proof options can sometimes lack the necessary structural weight to carry flavors across your palate, resulting in a thin, watery mouthfeel.
At 107 proof, the alcohol is prominent enough to provide a fantastic, viscous mouthfeel and carry complex aromatic compounds directly to your senses, but it is restrained enough that you do not need to add a single drop of water to unlock the flavor profile. It delivers the intensity, the legs, and the rich oily texture of a high-end pour without the punishing ethanol sting. It is approachable yet intensely flavorful, making it the ultimate format for both casual sipping and rigorous analytical tasting.
Tasting the Lineup: Wild Turkey Saffell and Baker's 7
To really test our theory, we put together a killer lineup of 107-proof bottles for a recent recording session, stepping well beyond the standard, everyday bottles everyone already knows. We wanted to see how different mash bills, ages, and distilling philosophies performed at this exact proof point.
We kicked things off with the Wild Turkey Saffell. Part of the legendary Whiskey Barons collection and selected by master distiller Eddie Russell, this release is rumored to include whiskey in the 13-to-14-year-old range. On the nose, it gives off a very distinctive, slightly quirky sharpie marker note alongside classic Wild Turkey bite, heavy rye spice, fresh mint, and an unexpected, deeply satisfying nutty finish. It leans heavily on the rye side of the spectrum. While it can be a bit polarizing if you are looking for a sweet, mellow dessert pour, it proved to be far better and more complex than we initially remembered.
Next up was Baker's 7. Specifically, our bottle was aged 7 years and 3 months, barreled back in March of 2013. The nose here was quite pleasant, offering bright citrus zest, zero ethanol off-putting vapors, and fantastic, oily legs clinging to the glass. However, the palate took a turn. It leaned aggressively rye-forward and finished with a bitter, medicinal, almost NyQuil-like aftertaste. While whiskey is entirely subjective and some might appreciate that herbal depth, it didn't win us over, proving that even a great proof point cannot completely rescue a polarizing finish.
When Bottles Fail: The Trackside Founder's Release and the Table of Shame
Every great tasting needs a baseline of reality, and sometimes reality tastes a bit like a barnyard. Enter the Trackside Founder's Release. Bottled by Trackside in Crestwood and sharing stylistic associations with well-known industry names, this wheated 107-proof expression had high expectations surrounding it.
Unfortunately, expectations and reality collided in the worst possible way. From the moment the cork was pulled, the nose was dominated by the unmistakable, unpleasant aroma of stale popcorn and raw field corn. On the palate, that youthful, unrefined grain character only intensified. It lacked the oak integration, the depth, and the complexity we expect from a bottle sitting at this price and age tier. It didn't take much deliberation for us to make our final verdict: this bottle was summarily and joyfully banished to our infamous table of shame. It serves as a reminder that proof is only one piece of the puzzle—good distillation, proper aging, and quality sourcing still reign supreme.
Heavy Hitters: Buffalo Trace 15-Year Wheated Experimental and Ass Pocket Whiskey
After washing away the taste of stale popcorn, we moved on to the heavy hitters of the evening, and this is where the 107-proof format truly began to flex its muscles. First up was the Buffalo Trace 15-year wheated experimental release. This expression hits all the right historic notes: it utilizes a low barrel-entry proof, was aged on a high warehouse floor resulting in substantial evaporation, and—crucially—was non-chill filtered.
The resulting liquid was nothing short of breathtaking. We found deep, mature oak, rich caramel, an exceptionally long finish, and a punchy mid-palate that smoothly transitioned into a sweet, lingering finish. When you compare the profile of this experimental pour to legendary unicorn bottles like Pappy Van Winkle 15, you realize how much lower entry proofs and traditional handling methods elevate the spirit. We are massive advocates for non-chill filtering at Bourbon Brass and Beyond, and this bottle proved why stripping out those natural fats and oils is a crime against flavor.
We also tasted Ass Pocket Whiskey Lot 3, a 15-year-old expression that is notoriously difficult to track down. Non-chill filtered and sitting right at 107 proof, this pour brought an incredible dance of rye characteristics, sharpie notes, bright orange, pear, rich caramel, cooling mint, and burnt sugar. It offered a remarkably well-rounded and drinkable experience that had us constantly reaching back into the glass for another sip.
Continuing the Ass Pocket Whiskey journey, we also sampled APW Lot 7, aptly named "The Search." A limited release created in collaboration with Derek Trucks and Danny Wimmer Productions, this straight bourbon at 107 proof introduced a gorgeous, decadent banana note on the nose. It delivered a full-on Bananas Foster dessert character layered with rich caramel and warming baking spice. It was an absolute home run.
Final Rankings and Our Favorite 107-Proof Bourbons
When the dust settled and the glasses were empty, we had to tally our scores and crown our champions. While the Wild Turkey Saffell brought great spice and the Baker's 7 brought gorgeous legs (despite the medicinal finish), and while the Trackside Founder's Release rightfully earned its spot in whiskey purgatory, the top tier belonged entirely to the champions of mid-proof balance.
The Buffalo Trace 15-year wheated experimental stood out as a leading contender for both of us, offering profound age and complexity without losing its drinkability. Meanwhile, the Ass Pocket Whiskey releases—both Lot 3 and Lot 7 (The Search)—showcased just how much nuance, dessert-like sweetness, and oily mouthfeel a 107-proof whiskey can deliver when expertly sourced and bottled without chill-filtration.
Ultimately, 107 proof gives you the best of all possible worlds. It is strong enough to stand up to ice, water, or a cocktail, yet nuanced enough to enjoy neat while picking apart dozens of distinct tasting notes for hours on end.
If you want to hear the full banter, the live reactions to every single pour, and our deeper dives into aviation disruptions, holiday merch, and the absolute absurdity of the Trackside release, you need to listen to the complete discussion. Check out the 107 PROOF Bourbon Line Up episode right now over at Bourbon Brass and Beyond. Grab your favorite mid-proof pour, drop us a comment with your own favorite 107-proof bourbon, and as always, keep raising a glass to great whiskey and great company!