Welcome to Bourbon, Brass & Beyond!
Nov. 10, 2026

Tasting the Elite: Reviewing Heaven Hill's 19-Year, 90th Anniversary, and 22-Year Heritage Collection

Tasting the Elite: Reviewing Heaven Hill's 19-Year, 90th Anniversary, and 22-Year Heritage Collection

Welcome back, bourbon lovers! If you are anything like us, you know that the world of high-end, allocated American whiskey is a whirlwind of hype, astronomical secondary prices, and legendary bottles that few will ever actually get to taste. But every so often, an opportunity comes along to pull the cork on some truly elite heavyweights like this Heaven Hill bourbon review. Recently on the podcast, we had the immense privilege of sitting down with a very special guest to taste three extraordinary expressions from one of Kentucky's most historic producers: Heaven Hill Distillery. Not only were we exploring the upper echelon of ultra-aged bourbon, but we were also marking a solemn and significant milestone in bourbon history—the 30th anniversary of the devastating Heaven Hill fire, alongside a heartfelt tribute for Veterans Day. To hear the complete conversation, the live reactions, and our in-depth discussions, be sure to listen to our accompanying audio feature, Heaven Hill Distillery High-End Bangers and Veteran's Day Special with Chief; Ep. 105.

In this post, we are going to expand on those tasting notes, break down the science of aging versus taste, look at how these masterclasses in distillation stack up against legends like Pappy Van Winkle, and give you our final definitive rankings. Pour yourself a finger of your favorite daily drinker, get comfortable, and let us dive straight into the tasting notes.

Introduction: Honoring Veterans and Remembering the Heaven Hill Fire

Before we ever brought a glass to our lips, it felt essential to ground our tasting in the rich, sometimes heartbreaking history of Heaven Hill. Thirty years ago, a catastrophic fire destroyed the main distillery and hundreds of thousands of barrels of maturing whiskey, threatening the very existence of a storied family-owned operation. Instead of crumbling, Heaven Hill rose from the ashes, expanding their footprint, acquiring historic brands, and continuing to craft some of the most sought-after bourbon in the world.

We also took time during our session to honor Veterans Day, thanking the brave men and women who have served our country, as well as the families who support them. We were joined by Chief Master Sergeant Patrick Kilgore (retired)—you can find him online as Chief's Bourbon Cabinet—who brought his incredible palate and deep appreciation for history to the table. Toasting our veterans with some of the finest amber liquid ever produced in Kentucky felt like the ultimate way to pay our respects. With history and gratitude guiding us, we turned our attention to the glass.

Tasting Notes: The Oak-Forward 19-Year Wheated Whiskey

The first bottle on our docket was a magnificent 19-year-old wheated whiskey bottled at 100 proof. Now, when bourbon enthusiasts hear "wheated whiskey" and "19 years old," the mind immediately jumps to expressions like Old Fitzgerald or certain legendary allocated unicorns. Naturally, comparisons to the classic Old Fitzgerald decanter series were inevitable, but this pour carved out its own unique identity.

On the nose, this expression leans heavily into its age. It is unmistakably oak-forward, yet it manages to retain a softness that prevents the wood from overpowering the spirit. Swirling the glass reveals rich layers of bright orange peel, buttery caramel, and a distinctly comforting note of warm toast. Because it is bottled at 100 proof, it drinks remarkably easy, belying its nearly two decades inside charred oak.

On the palate, that orange and caramel interplay continues, supported by a dense, structural backbone of mature oak. The finish is impressively long, lingering on the palate with a warm, comforting hug. While traditionalists might argue whether a wheated recipe can handle 19 full years in a Kentucky rickhouse without becoming overly woody, Heaven Hill proved here that expert cask management makes all the difference. It is softer and more mellow than some younger, punchier wheated offerings, offering a masterclass in elegance over raw power.

Age Versus Taste: Breaking Down the Heaven Hill 90th Anniversary 9-Year

Next up, we pivoted from ultra-aged maturity to a bottle that completely flips the modern bourbon narrative on its head: the Heaven Hill 90th Anniversary 9-Year-Old bourbon, bottled at 107 proof. This release is a fascinating blend composed of 70 percent nine-year-old traditional bourbon and 30 percent nine-year-old bourbon aged in heavy-char barrels.

In an era where consumers routinely chase double-digit age statements—believing that older automatically equals better—the 90th Anniversary release serves as a delicious reality check. As we discussed on the show, taste simply has to matter more than the number on the label. This nine-year-old pour punches so far above its weight class that it easily holds its own against legendary older siblings, with the hosts noting that it comfortably hangs with an Elijah Craig 12-year.

On the nose, the heavy-char influence works absolute magic, bringing forward waves of velvety vanilla, dark brown sugar, and toasted marshmallow. Pouring it into the glass reveals incredible, viscous legs that cling to the side like syrup. It is balanced, remarkably vibrant, and delivers an explosion of flavor that proves you do not need twenty years in the wood to create a transcendent drinking experience. Furthermore, when you look at the projected MSRP, this bottle represents an absolute home run in terms of value for money in today's inflated market.

The Crown Jewel: Reviewing the Heritage Collection 22-Year at 129.2 Proof

If the 19-year wheated whiskey was an exercise in elegance and the 90th Anniversary was a triumph of blending, the final pour was nothing short of a crown jewel. We poured the Heaven Hill Heritage Collection 22-Year-Old, pulled from the notoriously storied Y Rickhouse floors five and six.

Clocking in at a formidable 129.2 proof, this bottle commands respect from the second it hits the table. High-proof, ultra-aged bourbons are notorious for a common pitfall: over-oaking. When a whiskey spends over two decades interacting with wood, it runs the risk of tasting like liquid furniture polish. Yet, Heaven Hill’s master distillers somehow performed alchemy here. This 22-year-old monster is deeply done, featuring profound notes of dark charred oak, rich cacao, and deep, molasses-laden caramel. As the glass breathes, delicate notes of stone fruit begin to develop, adding an unexpected layer of complexity.

What blew all of us away—Chief and Dan included—was the sheer drinkability of this pour. At nearly 130 proof, you would expect a blazing heat that demands a splash of water or a large ice cube. Instead, it drinks with a shocking smoothness, offering a rich, mouth-coating viscosity and a finish that seems to last for hours. It is undeniably a special-occasion pour. When you consider the angel's share, the low barrel yields, and the intense labor required to safely shepherd a whiskey through 22 years of Kentucky summers and winters, the rarity of this liquid becomes painfully clear.

Head-to-Head: How These Heavyweights Compare to Pappy and Elijah Craig

You cannot taste bottles of this caliber without entering the realm of heavyweight comparisons. Naturally, the conversation turned toward the heavy hitters of the bourbon world: Pappy Van Winkle and Heaven Hill's own legendary Elijah Craig line (such as the 15-year and 21-year expressions).

When stacking the Heritage Collection 22-Year against elite competition, Chief made a bold declaration that got our entire chat room buzzing. He noted that, at this stage in his whiskey journey, he would gladly pick the Heaven Hill 22-Year over a bottle of Pappy Van Winkle 23. While Pappy 15 remains a gold standard for many, the extreme age on the Pappy 23 often crosses the threshold into excessive dryness and bitter oak tannins. Heaven Hill’s 22-year-old release manages to avoid that trap entirely, maintaining a luscious sweetness and structural integrity that leaves older wheated legends in the dust.

We also compared notes against the Elijah Craig lineage, marveling at how Heaven Hill’s traditional mashbill scales across different age brackets. These comparisons highlight why blind tastings are so essential—and spoiler alert, we even mapped out an upcoming blind tasting for Episode 106 to test our palates without the bias of labels and prestige.

Final Rankings, MSRP Value, and the Verdict

So, how did these three magnificent pours shake out in the end? While all three represent the pinnacle of American whiskey craftsmanship, a clear hierarchy emerged during our tasting session.

Unanimously, Dan and Chief agreed that the Heritage Collection 22-Year-Old stands proudly at the top of the podium. Its breathtaking complexity, perfect balance of dark cacao and rich caramel, and unbelievable drinkability at 129.2 proof make it a unicorn pour of the highest order. Coming in a very close and respectable second is the oak-forward 19-year wheated whiskey, offering a softer, more meditative sipping experience. Rounding out our trio is the 90th Anniversary 9-Year-Old—a bottle that proves age statements are secondary to pure, unadulterated flavor, and one that offers arguably the best value per dollar of the entire lineup.

When discussing the secondary market versus estimated MSRP values—with the Heritage Collection hovering in that coveted $299 to $349 range—we always come back to one core philosophy: whiskey is meant to be opened, shared, and enjoyed with friends, veterans, and loved ones. Do not let these bottles gather dust on a shelf; pour them, savor them, and celebrate the moments that matter.

Thank you again to Chief for driving out and sharing his incredible expertise with us. Make sure to check him out online @chiefsbourboncabinet on Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok. And for a deeper dive into the tasting room banter, live reactions, and complete historical context, listen to Heaven Hill Distillery High-End Bangers and Veteran's Day Special with Chief; Ep. 105 right now. Until next time, friends—pour 'em heavy, and cheers to all who have served!

Related Episode

105
Nov. 10, 2026

Heaven Hill Distillery High-End Bangers and Veteran's Day Special with Chief; Ep. 105

Bourbon Brass and Beyond: 30 Years After the Heaven Hill Fire, Plus Three Special Pours Dan Sneddon and Bob Hird are joined by Chief Master Sergeant Patrick Kilgore (retired) to mark 30 years since the Heaven Hill fire and to honor Veterans Day. They thank veterans and the families who support them, toast them, then taste three Heaven Hill elite bottles: 19 Year, 90th Anniversary, and 22 Year Heritage Collection. #bourbon #whiskey #heavenhilldistillery #elijahcraig #oldfitzgerald #wheated ...