Welcome to Bourbon, Brass & Beyond!
Nov. 10, 2026

Heaven Hill Distillery High-End Bangers and Veteran's Day Special with Chief; Ep. 105

Heaven Hill Distillery High-End Bangers and Veteran's Day Special with Chief; Ep. 105
Bourbon, Brass & Beyond
Heaven Hill Distillery High-End Bangers and Veteran's Day Special with Chief; Ep. 105

Bourbon Brass and Beyond: 30 Years After the Heaven Hill Fire, Plus Three Special Pours

Dan Sneddon and Bob Hird are joined by Chief Master Sergeant Patrick Kilgore (retired) to mark 30 years since the Heaven Hill fire and to honor Veterans Day. They thank veterans and the families who support them, toast them, then taste three Heaven Hill elite bottles: 19 Year, 90th Anniversary, and 22 Year Heritage Collection.

#bourbon #whiskey #heavenhilldistillery #elijahcraig #oldfitzgerald #wheated #toastedbarrel #aged #history #heavenhillfire #veteransday #bourbonbrassandbeyond #chiefsbourboncabinet

Tasting Highlights

  • 19-year wheated whiskey (100 proof): Oak-forward and softer than Old Fitzgerald, with orange, caramel and toast and a long finish.
  • Heaven Hill 90th Anniversary 9-year (107 proof): A blend of 70% nine-year bourbon and 30% nine-year bourbon aged in heavy-char barrels. Mellow, vanilla, velvety, with great legs. The hosts say taste should matter more than age, and they see strong value for MSRP. They say it hangs with Elijah Craig 12.
  • Heritage Collection 22-year (129.2 proof): From Y Rickhouse floors five and six, 2026 release. Dark oak, deeply done caramel and cacao, with stone fruit later. Rich, long and surprisingly drinkable for almost 130 proof, and not too oaky.

Ranking and Comparisons

  • Dan and Chief agree the 22-year stands above the other two, though all three are excellent.
  • Chief would pick the Heaven Hill 22 over Pappy 23 at this point, though Pappy 15 remains a favorite.
  • The hosts compare it with Pappy 23, Elijah Craig 21 and Elijah Craig 15, and suggest a future blind tasting (next Episode #106).
  • They call the 22 a special-occasion pour, discuss the effort and low yield behind a 22-year whiskey, and estimate MSRP around $299-$349 against much pricier aged bottles.

Timestamps

  • (0:01) Welcome
  • (0:30) Heaven Hill fire anniversary and the lineup
  • (1:00) Veterans Day tribute
  • (1:36) Why Heaven Hill
  • (2:05) 19-year wheated whiskey specs
  • (2:32) First tasting
  • (4:18) Orange and caramel notes
  • (5:06) Oak and age
  • (6:36) Comparing it with Old Fitz
  • (7:39) Heaven Hill 90th Anniversary
  • (8:24) Nine-year release: age vs. taste
  • (9:31) Nose and proof
  • (10:26) Velvety vanilla
  • (11:37) Taste, presentation and value
  • (13:26) Heritage Collection 22-year
  • (14:19) Comparison to George T. Stagg
  • (14:43) Opening bottles to enjoy them
  • (16:08) Oak, caramel and cacao
  • (17:34) MSRP and rarity
  • (18:04) Stone fruit develops
  • (19:05) Proof and value
  • (22:05) Ranking the 22-year
  • (22:45) Where it sits among Heaven Hill
  • (24:28) Proposed Elijah Craig 21 blind tasting
  • (25:26) Pappy comparisons
  • (27:14) Flagship age-stated bourbons compared
  • (28:13) Aging and oak balance
  • (29:10) Final verdict
  • (30:12) Toast and closing

We want to thank Chief for driving out for the podcast! Please check him out @chiefsbourboncabinet on IG, YouTube, and TikTok.

You can also check out Bourbon, Brass & Beyond at https://www.bourbonpod.com or on IG, YouTube, TikTok, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Deezer, and Amazon Music.

Thank you to all who have served. Cheers to you!

Dan, Bob and Chief: Good evening. What are you doing tonight? Welcome back to Bourbon Brass and Beyond. Tonight we are joined by Chief Patrick Kilgore. Welcome. Thank you for having me. My second show. Yeah. My second show. This is great. So in the first show, Chief said, Yeah, let us know. We'll be there. And and here he is. We're we're doing it. tonight is a gonna be a fun night with Heaven Hills. it's the anniversary of their fire. Yes. So 30 years. And so we're gonna start off with the Heaven Hill nineteen, the the wheated, and work our way to the 90th and then the Heaven Hill 22. All are supposed to be very good bottles. I I have cracked them, but yeah, they're all very good. But welcome. And it's also Veterans Day. That's exactly, yes. one of our I would say greatest holidays that we have. I just want to say to my fellow vets out there, thank you for your service, but I also want to bring it up to the family members who supported those military members currently serving and the veterans, thank you for everything that you've done. we could not do it without you. So you are the unsung heroes. Absolutely. Thank you. Thank you for your service. Yeah, we appreciate it. Well, this is it. Let's have a drink to them. So we did the E. H. Taylor last time and it was phenomenal. And I told you then that Heaven Hill really is that is that that is my favorite. That's my go-to. I love Elijah Craig. And we're starting, you know, with three bottles tonight that I have not had. So I'm really looking forward to it. Well, the the 19 It's a hundred proof, fifty percent alcohol, nineteen year straight whiskey, straight wheat whiskey, I apologize, and fifty seven percent wheat, thirty seven percent corn, and twelve percent malted barley. And that's what makes it a a wheated whiskey. So good. Well cheers everybody. Cheers. Cheers. It's so oaky and just it's so good. Yeah. I hope if you're out there with us that you're able to grab grab this bottle and join us because wow. If not you're really missing out. Yeah. Man, that is the nose is crazy on that. The nose is crazy, but a beautiful color, right? You know, look at the legs on that. it's just hanging on. It's just hanging on. Beautiful. So I get similar notes to old fits, like the Heaven Hills Old Fitz. Yes. But it just seems to be so much softer. Yeah. What's the wheat? I mean, obviously it's carrying some up. Source. It is softer. I have to say that the old fits, I it's a bit more complex. Yeah. I gotta go in, I gotta go in for the taste. We did these before, haven't we? We were at least a couple of them, I thought. Maybe we were just down here one day. I don't know. That's that's it's quite possible. It's very possible. It was probably after a podcast and we're like, hey, you know what else we got over here? Yeah. It's really bad. That's why you somewhat remember it. Yeah. Well it's funny though. No commitment. It always turns into like, Hey, what what else do you have? I come over with a couple and the next thing it turns itself into where did the night go? It's definitely turning into a wheated night now, so That is delicious. Yeah. I do get a little bit of citrus on it though. a an orange flavor over top. It's got that sweet caramel on the on the tip of the tongue. And then it brightens up as it moves back. What's the proof on this? Hundred. One hundred, right? One hundred. This it tastes i it it's carrying itself higher. and I say that because the finish on it is very long, for me. And I'm feeling it throughout the whole palette. Yeah. Yeah. You know, which is quite quite pleasant for Yeah, it's just toasty goodness in there. It's just Well you nail it. It's toasty. Yeah. Yeah. It's just The nose on it is just s so thorough. I Yeah. It's gonna get better from here? Wait a minute. Yeah. And I love the oakiness. So I'm some people consider themselves proof horse. I'm I'm an oak hor. I give me the age. Give I just give me age and if you could definitely do a double oak, I'm Man sign me up for anything. The wood for double double oak is always crazy good to me. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. yeah. tasting this really justifies again so I've been looking for this, right? I'm one of those individuals that you can get it online, but I think the victory is when you can find it on a shelf. Yeah, right. Or you can trade it with a friend and swap out. I think that's the victory and after, you know, really, you having a couple of good tastes justifies why I'm still looking for this this b this bottle. That flavor does hold though too. It just lasts. For a hundred proof. it's it's just good, man. Yeah. I don't know. What would you what would you compare that to? So I would say it has a little more vanilla or some more vanillins than like a standard old fits, but I would compare it to that seven old fit seventeen. I I would like to take you up on that and try that later, you know, see see what it goes to it. how that goes it bangs against it, right? Yeah, this is good stuff. Yeah. So if you if you've tried this and you know drop it in the comments, you know, let me know what do you think about it. I think it's definitely justifies continuing the hunt for me to to come find this bottle, you know what I mean? Yeah, it's something you wanted in the first place. Now you get a taste of it. Now I definitely be better. Did you? Yeah, I rinsed. So Heaven Hill Distillery, 90th anniversary. Yes. Nine year. This is a this is a nine year. Seventy eight percent corn, ten percent rye, twelve percent malted barley. So it is seventy percent Kentucky Strait bourbon whiskey that's nine year old, and then thirty percent Kentucky Strait bourbon whiskey aged in heavy char barrels, nine year old. I wonder if that's how they get the the color difference between that nine year and these others is not that big of a difference in my book. Like, is it the heavy char that they're pulling out of that? Or is it just Secret order juice the title. Yeah, y y that's a good question. I don't know i if y'all recall, so this came out very early in the in in the in the year. And there was a lot of talk about people can say a ninety the nineth anniversary. This is what you come out with is is a nine year, right? Yeah. But at the same time, there's some people that I I really respect. have done blind taste tests comparing this, this nine year with some really bangers and this has come out. This has come out on top. Yeah. So and we've talked about this the the last show that we were with, is that you can't you can't look at just age. Yep. Right? You've got to go by taste. And if you open it up just to taste, you'll find out that you there's There's a lot of bourbon out there that you could really enjoy and if you would just give it a chance. So it's got such a nice nose too as well. It's a little bit I don't want to call it mellow. I don't think that's as vanilla y, as charred as the other. No. But the no it's very, very similar on the nose. Like you can tell that they're cousins. But but it's half the age. Yeah. well, and don't even know. Like and again, it's still a nine year, let's say those words. But it doesn't have the heavy ethanol, like it doesn't drink like a young bourbon, that's for sure. Sure it's half the age. And but this one is a hundred and seven proof. You know You take and look at it some of the Elijah Craig, right? they really knock it out apart, those higher ages. Yeah. Wow. Yeah, it doesn't taste that is younger either. No, it does not taste young. it's velvety. Yeah. It's got a great mouthfeel to it. It's soft, right? Yeah. But that vanilla is just kicking down the door. I think velvety is a really good word for that. you talk about mouthfeel. This I velvite is the right word for that. I'll I'll that's Alright, okay, so we've had this, right? This is older, but just look at the legs on that thing. Yep. I wish I could, I wish I could show you guys it's just dripping and hanging on. Let's see if I can that is just Yeah, can you find one? That's crazy, folks. I really wish I could share that with you. That is just crazy. There's Bob's that. That is amazing. Yeah. That is. That is beautiful. That's some really good I really hope that y you're all able to join us with us and and you have one of these bottles open. The color, the the legs, the taste is not a nine year. No, I'll agree with that. No. That is not a nine year. And the thing, the price on this, MSRP used. Yeah. Crazy good. This is well worth it. This is something that that you could, you know, purchase in you know, especially during the holidays and stuff like coming up, you could drop a hundred, a hundred and fifty and it's get it's a beautiful presentation. It's in a nice box, right? and the taste is just a banger. Very very vanilla fruit. I think it's I think it's It's actually shorter, It doesn't hang around as much as the as the 19. Yeah, no, I agree. But but it's to be expected, okay, right? You got a nineteen versus a nine, right? Even with the extra proof, it's I don't think it's enough to make a difference. That's the seven points does nothing. But I'll tell you what, it hangs around with any Elijah Craig 12 year. Easy. Easy. That was delicious. Do I have to drink this 22-year-old Heavenhill? No, you don't have to. Okay. You don't have to. I'll do it for you. Twist my arm on this one. So the Heavenhill Heritage Collection, aged 22 years, 129.2 proof, 78% corn, 10% rye, 12% malted barley. And it is from the Y Rick House. Fifth and sixth floor. That release twenty twenty six. It's so dark. So this is like the George T. Stagg of Heaven Hill. Yeah. Yeah, okay, so what? y you get stags around fifteen year, right? This is a twenty two. Twenty two year. Yeah. Wow. And I've got to ask I've got to ask how many are there out there like myself that might have this bottle sitting on a shelf and there's no plans of opening it because they're holding it for investment and you're absolutely missing out on that nose is so nice. That is delicious. I mean and and as you can see, I I open every bottle. You do? Th there there is no There is no hesitation. each bottle is made to be open. We're just correct. It's just stuff we've not made it to yet, not stuff we're avoiding. Right. Yeah. hate living next to Dan. It sucks for all these reasons. I know. I I'll imagine if you decided to walk across the street so spending the day, you know, the time with him on today is just like, you know, he's really convinced me I just need to go home and open up some bottles, right? You and whiskey o is yeah, that's his theory too, is open. If you got it, you open it right away. Yeah. What's your proof again? 129.2. Yeah, basically 130. Yeah. Wow. If you like the oak, it's there. There's nothing overpowering. That there's no ethanol with I mean for twenty-two year. Yeah. This is Well I think that's the advantage for sure. Yes. It's knocked the it's knocked the proof off of it, I guess. And that color out of the three bottles, I mean, d there is a difference. That that's just amazing. You get the you get the flavor of the char and then It's like a almost not burnt, but a deeply done caramel. the I think the deeper like we tried that Yellowstone. It's very butterscotchy. This is same but darker. You're exactly right that it's a much it's gotta be just a barrel that it's sat around in that long. Almost like a cacao or cocoa. What is that again? Cacao. Mm. Are you polling off any dark fruits? Just a little bit on the aftertaste. On the aftertaste. That's right. the just just in the sides of the mouth I I'm getting. Yeah. It's coming in it's coming in as the door is closing. Just to to introduce itself. So MSRP on this was three hundred and I think it was it was either 299 or 349. I think I'm gonna say 349. I remember when this came out, Virginia ABC. I started, I tried running all over the place to find this and could not find it. I was able to secure one for MSRP and now You know what? I think I'm gonna have to open this up. Yeah. It's I think the only way we didn't get these in Ohio. We had to get these we got these off a distillery release? I can't remember w or was it off a I think this was a trade. I think we traded for this. But second sip, I get a lot more stone fruit. I'm getting a lot more fruit now on the second sip. And I always have a theory that, the the flavors layer as as you as you get a more viscous or more oily bourbon, correct the the each sip you're gonna get more of the flavors layering on your tongue. And I feel like this is one of those bourbons that each time you sip it, you're gonna get more and more of that flavor. And for me this time was as getting the stone fruit. Yeah, w what's I think what's allowing that, this does not For me, it's not a 129 proof. Right. It's allowing you to enjoy those flavors to come in. especially like I said, the fruitiness afterwards, like coming in and before the door closes. you know, for something that's almost 130 proof. Yeah. No. I really think Heaven Hill really knocked this out of the park. twenty two year. Can you w what else? What what what could you what could you look at that? So w what are you gonna say, the the Pappy Van Winkle twenty three? No, 'cause that's yeah that's only a what, a hundred and seven? Right? ninety five point six ninety yeah, ninety five, yeah, exactly. Right, n yeah, ninety five. Ninety five point six. So you're you got something close to a hundred and thirty, you know? Yeah. What What's gonna compete against this? you I think nothing that old, I guess, but I mean the only thing you've got close to that is probably some of the BTAC stuff maybe or I mean it's really the I you got Knob Creek. W so the the the Taylor BTAC. Yeah, it's what seventeen I think. Y yeah. And that's sitting at a hundred, right? Yeah. Well no you're right about still, but that's still that's only at a bottle and bond, right? Yep. This is not. Yeah, No, I give it up. I cheers to heaven hell. I to your point, I think it's a really hard bottle to produce. I mean, it's twenty two years, what's left in that? The yield is really, really low for that. So to produce what they produced took a lot of barrels and a lot of time to get there. Like the The value, not the value, I it's hard for me to say something that's three hundred dollars as value, but the the money that went into this bottle is a lot. that's the margin even at that price is not great. No, but you brought up a good point. Okay, so we're looking at I have nail product at twenty-two years. Yep. And Pappy twenty or twenty-three are sitting right around two thousand to three thousand. Right. Yep. And they're doing it for even secondary market is probably right right around currently now probably around five hundred. Yeah. Yeah. Right? So I think it really does hold a value. Yeah, no, I I'll agree with every yes, absolutely true. I just wanna keep on drinking. I don't wanna Yeah. This is very good. Little bit of the Kentucky hug. Yeah, but I don't think it's that bad. No. Like I the proof is there. But I don't think it's especially after the first two minutes a fairly big jump, but I would think for me out of the three, that really does run away, right? And I'm a I'm a wheated guy, but I would take that twenty two year every time. That's good. That's something you are definitely gonna want to sit around and drink it for a celebration, something that a special occasion. End of the work day. Well if you're Dan, yes. Crack it open base off the wall. Meeny meeny miny mo. But I say that as in this is really good. Yeah. No, I agree. How does this weigh up, do you think, out of the Heaven Hill products, where does this stand amongst all of them? I think it has the most flavor. and I say it like that for Heaven Hills. I think that There's so much flavor in each sip on that one. It's it's very deep, it's very rich. now I'm getting even more of the fruit, but it's also more caramely. It has a great lasting finish. I wouldn't think that there's many that follow that line. It's hard because of the proof that it's sitting at. but that Elijah Craig fifteen, that's a banger. Yeah. Right? and it's it's not at the same proof whatsoever, but that Elijah Craig fifteen is really complex, flavorful, you know, it really that one is under undervalued I think for what what they've done with that. Yeah. initially when we first tried the fifteen, the Elijah Craig, that I'd I had had the eighteen. Love the eighteen. And my buddy Nick had had the fifteen. So he brought that over. He had not had the eighteen yet. So we both got to try them for the first time. And I think that I mean we we both mutually agree that The fifteen was better than the eighteen topic. Correct. Correct. What I would like to do is I would like to take this, the twenty-two, and I would like to do a blind taste test against the twenty-one, the Elijah Craig twenty-one, and see wha how how does that stack how does that stack up? Yeah. Yeah. You know, and we say it because the Elijah Craig twenty-one is still so new and because the price point with that. It's just not it it has not been experienced enough. Right. Right. but I would I would love to do a blind taste test against the yeah. This and the and the Elijah Craig twenty one. Just to see. Just to see. That fifteen is delicious. And that twenty one is supposed to be just like right up there. Yeah. Maybe we can make that happen the next visit. Probably. Twist his arm a little bit, yeah. Yeah, it's early. You heard it folks right here. So the other question is how would it stack up against the Pappy twenty three? The proof difference is gonna make a difference here. It is. I I would I would say from what mine, I would b against the Pappy twenty-three, I would right now I would go with this. I think. I would not say that against a Pappy fifteen. It's so good. The Pappy fifteen is is outstanding. That's the sweet spot. Yeah. We've done them all, we've talked about I the fifteen still stays my favorite. and I I I don't know. But we could make that happen. literally we could take a break, come back, and we could we could try to see, you know, how that how would that stack up? Could we not take that? The Pappy twenty three, the Heaven Hill twenty two, and the Elijah Craig twenty one. And see how does it stand out? three outstanding, close to age. Yeah. Again, going like I said before, going with taste, don't look at proof. Yeah. and and see where it stands up. Because I would say all three really strong represent you know their industry quite well. Yeah. Right? Yeah, if they if you're gonna pick a flagship off each of those brands, you're in the right spot. that's the way I view it is you say the BTACs, but realistically these with the age statements become the top of the market for each of them. I I agree. Even above the BTACs. Yes. I I do too. Because th they they don't stand they're they're they're not the same, right? You you can't look at this against a George T Stagg It it's not the same. It's not even meant to be. Yeah. You know in in the same realm, right? even with the new E. H. Taylor BTAC, it's it's not meant to to go against this, you know. It it it really isn't. But you brought up a good point. Yeah. It's the we talked about E C before we were even in here that twenty one or eighteen's good, twenty one's good, but somehow fifteen is the sweet spot. Same thing with the back piece. Somehow the It is the in-betweenies that make the difference. I as a twenty-two year, I don't think it's overpowering. I don't think it's too oaky. I don't really I I think it's a really good mix. So if you're looking for something that's a high age statement like that, I it's good. It doesn't it doesn't fall into the this is so aged, it's super oaky. I don't like that. it's oaky, but it's not no, I don't think it is at all. No. No, I I think it is a really good representation of well aged bourbon. Correct. Whiskey. Correct. I think that yeah. Yeah. But until really until I the three line up, I couldn't tell you right now how how how would it go, you know? Yeah. Meant for another show though. Yeah. may maybe the next one. We'll see. All right. Well, I I think that Heaven Hills did knock it out of the parking. yeah. I think I Yeah. I think so. I think out out of this lineup, I think the twenty two for me stands head and shoulders over the other two. And each each one of these are fantastic. I agree. On on what it's all I mean I mean this really represent what a wheated you know whiskey's supposed to be. And when you get a nine year, I can't think of another nine year that would I'll agree with this to speed that out. I'll agree with that. that would sit against any 12 year easily, easily. But that 22, extremely impressive. It's not overbearing, you know, for oak. It's it's does not taste like a 129, you know, 129 proofs. Fantastic. Yeah. Yep. No, I'm happy with all those. Yeah, yeah. They're all good. Well, gentlemen, thank you. Don't say this is great. Appreciate it. Cheers. Cheers. Cheers. Well, what's left? I got some. Well, until the next one. thank you. Please like and subscribe and share. There we go. Chiefs Bourbon Cabinet, like, subscribe and share. And we appreciate you coming on. I my pleasure. That's it really was my pleasure. Yeah. Thanks for coming over. All right. Good night. Good night. Thanks, everybody.

Related to this Episode

Tasting the Elite: Reviewing Heaven Hill's 19-Year, 90th Anniversary, and 22-Year Heritage Collection

Welcome back, bourbon lovers! If you are anything like us, you know that the world of high-end, allocated American whiskey is a whirlwind of hype, astronomical secondary prices, and legendary bottles that few will ever actually get to taste. But eve…