Dan Sneddon, Bob Hird, and Chief Patrick Kilgore taste three well-aged bourbons side by side: Elijah Craig 21 (94 proof), Heaven Hill 22 (about 129 proof), and Pappy Van Winkle 23, the only wheated bourbon of the three.
Bourbon, Brass & Beyond: Legends in the Glass- Elijah Craig 21 vs. Heaven Hill 22 vs. Pappy 23
Dan Sneddon, Bob Hird, and Chief Patrick Kilgore taste three well-aged bourbons side by side: Elijah Craig 21 (94 proof), Heaven Hill 22 (about 129 proof), and Pappy Van Winkle 23, the only wheated bourbon of the three. The bottle was signed by Preston Van Winkle, and the hosts share stories from a recent visit with him. The verdict: all three are "number one," depending on what you want that night.
#pappyvanwinkle #heavenhill #elijahcraig #pappy23 #heavenhill22 #elijahcraig21 #bourbon #oldripvanwinkledistillery #prestonvanwinkle #whiskey #bourbonbrassandbeyond #chiefsbourboncabinet #buffalotrace #oldfitzgerald #wheated #singlebarrel
Highlights
* Elijah Craig 21: One host was first in line when the distillery released it. The nose brought lots of fruit, oak and some smoke. One host called it his pick "hands down," citing exploding fruit and no ethanol on a fresh bottle.
* Heaven Hill 22: The proof came through on the nose after the Elijah Craig. On the palate the hosts found stone fruit, raspberry and softer flavors. They said it is hard to compare fairly against two lower-proof bottles, and one host would pair it with a cigar.
* Pappy 23: More mellow, with creamy caramel, sweetness and oak. The hosts said it was long, approachable and kept getting better with each sip. They did not find the oakiness some people criticize.
* The Pappy bottle: A 2019 bottle, which would mean 1996 distillate. Preston identified the juice as Bernheim by smell. One host still prefers Pappy 15 to 23.
* Preston Van Winkle visit: About two and a half hours together. The hosts talked about his sense of legacy, family and responsibility, and a bottled-in-bond Old Fitzgerald from the 1960s.
* Value: The hosts said Elijah Craig 21 is available at the distillery for $299 and stands up against Pappy 23.
* Final picks: One host leaned Pappy, another chose Elijah Craig 21, and Heaven Hill 22 was praised for flavor and cigar pairing. Their closing point: palates differ, so nobody is wrong.
Timestamps
* (0:01) Lineup and opening the bottles
* (2:07) Pappy and cigars, plus the Heaven Hill 22
* (3:22) Nosing all three
* (4:37) Heaven Hill 22 nose and the proof gap
* (5:28) Pappy 23 nose: wheated, mellow, oaky
* (6:49) Nose favorites
* (10:42) Moving to the palate
* (11:23) Elijah Craig vs. Heaven Hill 22 flavors
* (13:01) Pappy 23 palate
* (14:34) Distillate story and Preston Van Winkle
* (16:10) Legacy and family heritage
* (18:08) Final picks
* (22:29) Buffalo Trace, Heaven Hill and the market
* (24:49) Elijah Craig 21 price and audience question
* (25:52) Next episode: Old Fitzgerald
Quote
"Every one of them is a number one. It depends what you're looking for during that pour."
Cheif's Bourbon Cabinet - on IG, YouTube, and TikTok @chiefsbourboncabinet
Bourbon, Brass & Beyond - https://www.bourbonpod.com
or Link Tree - https://linktr.ee/BourbonBrassBeyond